Who better to design the interface? With a designer or frontend developer?

Are at the prototyping stage of the project. I feel that the right person with whom to consult in terms of UI/UX, how best to arrange the elements so that they were convenient for the end user as easy to withdraw a lot of complex data. Your opinion?
July 8th 19 at 16:00
6 answers
July 8th 19 at 16:02
Solution
With the designer.
July 8th 19 at 16:04
Solution
With [independent] user [who is not related to the beneficiary]
I — the user. - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:07
The platform is designed from user to user, taking into account the wishes when collecting feedback. - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:10
: then you should discuss the opinions of three groups of people
writers IPAS/bekenturov for fast and flexible API
frontenders that will be cut interfaces in frameworks of the type bustrapa a dozen a day
the users for whom pretender will plow - marilyne_Roh commented on July 8th 19 at 16:13
July 8th 19 at 16:06
Solution
Of course a web designer, UI and UX - it's his job.
July 8th 19 at 16:08
Solution
Wikipedia says that me to web designer:
Web design (from the English. Web design) — the industry of web development and design variety, whose mission is to design user interfaces for web sites or web applications. The web designers design the logical structure of web pages, think over the most convenient solutions of information presentation and engaged in decorating a web project.
So it is: it is the responsibility of the designer. - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:11
designer - it problem solver - design is one thing - but the business problem to understand it more! the business will also need to know - and the front end - a little bit not that - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:14
I mean that any site head Asan on nailed little to understand trends we need to understand the psychology and logic - UI/UX - marilyne_Roh commented on July 8th 19 at 16:17
The wiki simply translated the English version, not realizing that a web designer and a web designer, it's a different concept

Good luck - otho.Mraz23 commented on July 8th 19 at 16:20
: What is different concepts? - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:23
: webdesigner not only draws, but also typesets - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:26
July 8th 19 at 16:10
815919be05164f0c9ec31a7dd103bdfb.png
July 8th 19 at 16:12
Of course, the convenience and performance necessary to speak with a "techie" and not "a humanist aesthetic", this would likely be the programmer, but often people do not take their.
Why about the convenience to speak with a techie? Wikipedia says I'm the web designer: Web design (from the English. Web design) — the industry of web development and design variety, whose mission is to design user interfaces for web sites or web applications. The web designers design the logical structure of web pages, think over the most convenient solutions of information presentation and engaged in decorating a web project. - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:15
: just techies don't like designers as they provide them a headache) - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:18
excuse me - talking nonsense - what the technician will understand how to sell designer needs to draw and to think - that if there is no designer - and web Studio is a separate person - the designer - marilyne_Roh commented on July 8th 19 at 16:21
: Head, you think you do not know, the situation don't know, people don't know well, I will try to explain "on fingers". Hurt you tooth. Wikipedia says that in this case, need a dentist. I get on the Internet write that I'm a great dentist. You will come to me to treat the teeth? If not, why not? - otho.Mraz23 commented on July 8th 19 at 16:24
: Drawing is neither here nor there, the topic starter asked not about aesthetics, but about convenience, and as "as easy to withdraw a lot of complex data", there is an important question and the performance that the designer can understand in performance? - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:27
can at least be interested in - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:30
: Moreover, it can also be a great "techie", but this is the ideal, but without "pink glasses"? - marilyne_Roh commented on July 8th 19 at 16:33
I don't know about perfect - but I think the concept of having to create and how it will be put on or in the screen))- need to have (sory for mistakes)) - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:36
In practice, the designer is an artist, and the art and the convenience of a priori incompatible, if you think about the convenience, then paint all makes no sense, "faster to a picture". - marilyne_Roh commented on July 8th 19 at 16:39
: "Head, you think you do not know, the situation don't know, people don't know well, I will try to explain "on fingers". "

What this pompous empty attack? - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 16:42
: Had to tell you this, because this is so, because it is important to answer your question, if you do not know the situation, it is necessary first to learn from those who know, and only then to draw conclusions, to protect the company's their opinion and get mad at "attacks" of those who disagree with you. - Dixie_Quigley commented on July 8th 19 at 16:45
: shta? Dear, you are completely unaware of my awareness and what I do. Therefore, let no empty assumptions. - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:48
: If asked, do not know. - mazie.Towne commented on July 8th 19 at 16:51
: Re-read my previous comment. And close the topic :) - mazie.Towne commented on July 8th 19 at 16:54
: Yes I care, but you and your users will not find it, if the so-called "designer", but actually "artist-scholar-aesthete", will be happy to design the interface of your software, easy such an interface will not be sure about the performance, I am silent, but almost all "designers" such is the situation. - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 16:57
: *facepalm* - mazie.Towne commented on July 8th 19 at 17:00
: Why are you so desperate to resist and you don't want to hear anything? Is it so hard to admit that you were wrong, and to listen to the advice of a man more competent in this matter? Your aim is to obtain convenient, high-performance interface, or to Balk like a sheep at all costs to remain unconvinced? - Bria.Medhurst commented on July 8th 19 at 17:03
: Dear "more competent", please! You are too arrogant, don't you think? Specifically Your comments on this issue is absolutely uninteresting to me. Besides, Your expertise clearly emphasizes the negative karma on habré (i.imgur.com/3aVhoLu.jpg). Relax. - mazie.Towne commented on July 8th 19 at 17:06
Yeah, "karma" on some articles that I write not for money but for fun and the article on that online was only one, and that I deleted (because I am so advised and I listen when you talk!) this, of course, figure...
But my good "karma" to other resources, which, incidentally, is "abruptly" Habra will, you somehow did not notice!
www.codeproject.com/Members/Rou1997
Apparently, it's you bad karma, and not online, but in the Soul! So to you only the bad and stick, and the good advice you give, you knot ready to tie, but would not listen! - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 17:09
: All does not justify. Your empty I don't need. All the best. - mazie.Towne commented on July 8th 19 at 17:12
The eternal dispute. I agree with Cooper in it. "Geek" will do what is convenient "techie" and would not think about ordinary users. This should engage a designer, not visual. - Dwight commented on July 8th 19 at 17:15

Find more questions by tags Web DevelopmentDesign