As there is a shutdown of the Internet in a single country from the outside world?

Inspired by
www.forbes.ru/news/321483-minkomsvyazi-reshilo-otd...
The newspaper's source in the government has assured that it is not about creating an analogue of the "Chinese firewall", but, in his words, "the ability to disconnect from the world and work in the country required"


1) How is it technically possible?
2) That is, we will not be able any information at all you can get for example with English-language resources on programming?
3) And will not be able to meet obligations to foreign counterparties, who now works over the Internet?

upd 4) How will this affect the banking system?
6 answers
July 9th 19 at 10:44
All such attempts led to the fact that the connection to the Network back
4. On the technical side: the banks can do transfers via teletype
Practical: margins on opertsii will greatly increase because of the "image" of the country in which the Bank is located

"The theory of boiling the frog," you will not notice the moment when all poravalit
I think that has a face that will be noticeable immediately, but it is impossible to go to the exchange and the English-speaking blogs even through a foreign proxy - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:47
by the time you still can have the opinion that "it may not need" - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 10:50
@sim3x
become a zombie or something? it is very unlikely. - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:53
: :)
some of the things that the day before could not even imagine yesterday was impossible, today became a reality - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 10:56
well, for me these things still beyond. for example, blocking of an entire host due to the presence of the site from the registry. and all think and not take for granted - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:59
mean of all other sites on the host, which are generally not in the business - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:02
July 9th 19 at 10:46
1) How is it technically possible?
This is not technically difficult, it is enough to have the necessary infrastructure in the country. Financially, it would be quite expensive.

2) That is, we will not be able any information at all you can get for example with English-language resources on programming?
Of course. To do this properly and shut off, to exclude the possibility of exchange of information. For example, in the case of a military conflict to prevent data loss, or block the flow of propaganda.

3) And will not be able to meet obligations to foreign counterparties, who now works over the Internet?
Well, Internet disconnection is an emergency mode. In the event of a flood, shake, volcanic eruption, or war, you also will not be able to meet its obligations to counterparties.

How will this affect the banking system?
As for the service of the population - already have their processing, it is working. And access to international banking platforms, you can leave need banks.
July 9th 19 at 10:48
cut the cable and ready , well the satellites are all lociki.
global disable is in the case of a full-scale war, in this case that you that your customers won't care, and fuck you Bank , when is the time to eat there will be nothing, and the money did not chew good.
as locadia satellites (technically)? - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:51
banned in Google - gives all garbage how to remove mail ru Sputnik) - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 10:54
: well, apparently you go into their console and disable them, so once the gps was turned off for the Russians and here we have grown probably GLONASS - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:57
that is, to operators of satellite Internet have access? - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 11:00
: you speak as if they are a separate state with a nuclear Arsenal. - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:03
don't understand how the government has access to private satellites of foreign companies. rocket if only... - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:06
the state can nationalize any time any company, trust us when we would disconnect from the Internet satellites will go out the same day. - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:09
as I understand it, now anyone can buy the satellite equipment in any point of the earth and adjust it to the appropriate satellite. what does privatization? most satellites are not our www.bbc.co.uk/staticarchive/84362c85326b667683d5cb... - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:12
: you seem to not understand the main thing, we are not disabled , and we , the exercises for that are, what do we do when we disconnect
well, here's how we disabled GPS? GPS anyone can buy , even I have the phone, and BAM we have disabled the GPS satellites and Russian is not working, no GPS, and the equipment are at all the satellites are spinning.
if we are going to disable it just by order prohibit , and if the companion astrit what a pirate then it will just come over and equipment satellite tucked in the ass and he immediately senses, and others who do not have a very stretched anus throw all sputnikovoe equipment.. - Eulalia22 commented on July 9th 19 at 11:15

I understand, but there are different opinions on this. there is another position, first you will need a special unit to train on searching satellites, i.e. the trapping of the signal, calculating, population, withdrawal, etc. and etc. plus, disconnect from the Internet customers who are paying for satellite Internet is clearly not in the hands of Western business, as the population in General and - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:18
in war all will not care for customers, all duraprene equipment for satellite and considered it very little, so just to take away a week of the people.
I don't think you really understand the power of the state and do not really understand why we are disconnected from the Internet
here is a real example cut off our gps and that someone was able to use it?
and you say Internet is not shut off, even though he no importance compared to GPS. - Eulalia22 commented on July 9th 19 at 11:21
July 9th 19 at 10:50
1. Technically - lock subnets on the border routers.
2. We can, but only those within the boundaries)
3. If you disconnect - how can they be run without a connection?! Only if you come to them)
And in China, or so we would be more interesting? - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:53
and how will this affect the banking system? - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 10:56
I don't know how to be, but "hamster" the old parsers with valuable information for development - the time has come) - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:59
In China, firewall - access blocked and restricted.
We also do your firewall, although less rigid than in China.

You're talking about something a little different - off is not just blocking traffic to certain resources that complete blocking of all traffic, even infrastructure.
Ie at least lock all the network's DNS servers, except for controlled. - marilyne_Roh commented on July 9th 19 at 11:02
: Here in China - this omission, so they write on gichaba all the mimicry of a single type of traffic for the other)
And we have, I think if slash, then slash by the formula:
deny all, except %whitelist-subnets% - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:05
In China, they block what you think is right. We also have a block, although to a lesser extent.
But neither China nor the us not cut off completely - makes no sense.
The point cut off will be in the case of a clear threat - then cut off everything and everyone.
Only here the challenge is not just to cut off the foreign network, but also to leave a healthy internal. - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:08
all the points:
1. "But neither China nor the us not cut off completely - makes no sense." - here, I hardly agree. The meaning is: to stop "borrowing" of source code and get people to think for themselves, to prevent "leakage" of strategically important algorithms and intellectual development.
But there are also cons!
Programmers/scientists will not be able to share the knowledge and experience to achieve a unified peaceful purposes in various areas of science, technology, cosmology, etc., which in turn will reduce the development progress throughout the world several times: the same algorithm will be developed in parallel in several countries.

2. "The point cut off will be in the case of a clear threat - then cut off everything and everyone." - here is the same as giving someone to ignite the fuse of explosives and once he does, come back later to pick up a match and say, "don't do that anymore!". After the match took - got rid of the obvious threat. And implicit, would be a clear destruction in just a few seconds (bypassing unnecessary to achieve the objective, the stage!)

3. and here "not just to cut off" and "leave a healthy internal"? It's obvious what's inside will leave, and of this no no (I wrote above). - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:11
:
The points
1)currently no one cuts off completely neither we, nor in China. You disagree?
Not cut off for one simple reason - it makes no sense.
Why cut off something that is beneficial and not a hindrance.

2)I do Not understand the meaning of your statements about the fuse.
The state should have the ability to control communications and media. If it has this capability - it is a weak state.

3)it is Very difficult to cut off so that the internal network worked smoothly.
At the moment it is not impossible. - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:14
: let's say, and there is information what exactly has been closed in China? - Eulalia22 commented on July 9th 19 at 11:17
: bfy.tw/602A - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:20
would the authors of the topics function to clean up the flood, would have removed it all. and I am afraid the topic is now banned... - Eulalia22 commented on July 9th 19 at 11:23
: I deleted my. the case for - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 11:26
July 9th 19 at 10:52
upd 4) How will this affect the banking system?

will introduce white lists
exactly, and there will be not only of the person/company, but also special. access to foreign the Internet!))) - carlie commented on July 9th 19 at 10:55
July 9th 19 at 10:54
How to do ?
Bang, cut off.

But seriously, in the country there is a limited number of cables from the border States, enough to supply powerful equipment to analyze the traffic on those cables, and to cut off the unwanted traffic -- and BAM you have an external Internet, although banks are working properly with SWIFT.

Find more questions by tags FreelanceJurisprudence in ITIndividual entrepreneurComputer networks